作　　者： ;

机构地区： 中国社会科学院法学研究所

出　　处： 《山西大学学报（哲学社会科学版）》 2007年第3期183-193,共11页

摘　　要： 文章对物权法草案(第五次审议稿)提出了12条修改意见:1．将第一条删去“根据宪法”四个字;2．将第五条删去“法律未作规定的,符合物权特征的权利,视为物权”;3．恢复物权法草案(第二次审议稿)第八条关于物权优先原则的规定“在特定的不动产或者动产上,既有物权也有债权的,优先保护物权。但法律另有规定的除外”; 4．修改第五十一条为“国家投资的道路、电力、通讯、天然气等公共设施,属于国家所有”;5．增加一条宗教财产归属的规定“寺庙、官观、教堂、清真寺的不动产和动产,属于宗教法人所有”;6．删去第六章中的“业主的”三个字,删去本章所有条文中的“业主”一语;7．修改第一百二十四条的承包期限;8．建议删去第一百八十五条;9．在动产质权一节增加关于“营业质权”的规定;10．将第二百二十八条中的(六)公路、桥梁收费权、(七)应收账款这两项删去;11．恢复第二次审议稿关于“让与担保”的规定;12．增加关于取得时效的规定;等等。文章对上述问题进行了全面、详尽的论证。 This paper advances 12 Amendments to the Property Rights Law Draft （the 5th Version）. They are： 1. leaving out the ＂according to the constitution＂ in article 1 ; 2. leaving out ＂the rights which law does not define and which conform to the character of the property rights are viewed as property rights. ＂ in article 5; 3. restoring the provision as to the priority principles of the property rights in article 8 in the Property Rights Law Draft （the 2nd Version） ：＂for the movable and immovable property with both property right and the creditor＇s right, property right has the priority to be protected; 4. revising the article 51 to be ＂the roads, electric power, communication, natural gas and other public facilities are owned by state＂ ; 5. adding a provision as to the ownership of religious property ＂the movable and immovable property of temples, churches and mosques are owned by religious legal person; 6. leaving out ＂owner＇s＂ in chapter 6 and ＂owner＂ in all articles; 7. revising the time term of contract; 8. suggesting leaving out article 185; 9. adding the provision as to ＂business pledge right＂; 10. leaving out ＂（6） the right of collecting the road and bridge toll and （7） fund receivable on account in article 124; 11. restoring the provision as to ＂transfer and guarantee＂ in the 2nd Version; 12. adding the provision as to the time limitation of obtaining. This paper makes a thorough and detail discussion on these problems above.

关 键 词： 物权法草案 第五次审议稿 修改意见

领　　域： [政治法律] [政治法律]